Barrataria Island Homes for Sale

Barrataria Island Homes for Sale

Welcome to Barrataria Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Florida. This picturesque subdivision offers a unique blend of coastal charm and modern living, making it an ideal destination for those seeking a tranquil lifestyle while staying close to the vibrant culture of one of America’s oldest cities.

Barrataria Island is characterized by its stunning waterfront views, lush landscapes, and a strong sense of community. Residents enjoy easy access to pristine beaches, scenic parks, and the historic sites that St. Augustine is renowned for. Whether you’re an outdoor enthusiast looking to kayak through the serene waters or a history buff eager to explore the cobblestone streets of the historic district, Barrataria Island serves as a perfect base for your adventures.

The homes for sale in this sought-after subdivision range from elegant single-family residences to modern townhouses, each thoughtfully designed to blend seamlessly with the natural beauty of the area. Many of these homes feature open-concept layouts, spacious backyards, and stunning views of the surrounding landscape, making them perfect for both relaxation and entertaining.

With a variety of amenities nearby, including shopping, dining, and recreational facilities, Barrataria Island promises a lifestyle of convenience and leisure. Whether you’re looking to settle down or invest in a vacation home, this enchanting community offers a unique opportunity to experience the best of coastal living in St. Augustine. Discover your dream home in Barrataria Island today, and start creating memories that will last a lifetime!

Newest Barrataria Island Homes for Sale

$1,445,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2166767 MLS
A rare gem, completely reimagined and rebuilt down to the studs in 2017, this luxurious 4-bedroom, 3-bath Mediterranean-style masterpiece is the ultimate coastal retreat. Perfectly positioned between the Intracoastal Waterway and the Atlantic Ocean, this elegant residence includes a full 1-bedroom, 1-bath in-law suite for added versatility. Set on over a 1/3-acre double parcel, this property was designed with entertaining in mind. Wraparound balconies and covered first-floor decks showcase stunning views of the ocean and serene saltwater canal, while multiple boat docks and lifts cater to water enthusiasts. As you pull up, the spacious yard and circular drive gives plenty of space to soak up the sun and ocean breeze! Step inside, and a scrollwork, iron spiral staircase leads you to the open living area. A family room with ocean views provides an ideal space to set up a pool table or have a family movie night. An arched opening leads to the open concept kitchen, living room, and dining room. gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream, equipped with quartzite countertops, custom wood cabinets, a stunning Mediterranean-style backsplash, and a luxurious AGA Legacy gas range. The living space boasts magnificent views of the canal, while sliders of the living and dining rooms lead to a covered, walk-around balcony offering stunning sunset and sunrise views. Back inside, the master bedroom, located off the living room, features a separate Florida Room with panoramic views and an en-suite bathroom complete with a walk-in closet, dual vanity, and tub/shower. Across the home, two additional bedrooms share a guest bathroom for added privacy. The attached in-law suite was rebuilt down to the studs in 2017, has a separate entrance offers over 450sf with a kitchenette. Downstairs also offers an office/studio with closets that could function as a 5th bedroom. This home is perfect for water sports enthusiasts seeking the ultimate Florida lifestyle. A sturdy bulkhead gives way to a covered 7,500 boat lift, platform boat lift, a floating dock 30' out into the water and deck area to enjoy! This home is complete with updated A/C systems, electrical, plumbing and the recent clay tile roof from Spain. So come, indulge, and savor the beauty of this idyllic residence!

8851 A1a S, St. Augustine

Start Your Search
© 2026 Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. This data is up-to-date as of . For the most current information, contact Gail DeMarco.